display | more...

The difference between poetry and prose is, to my mind, is one of communication. Not so much what is communicated, but how.

In prose, the main medium of communication is the content; the structure is there mostly to help the reader understand the content better. You use words with relatively concrete meanings which your audience is expected to know, and you fit them into a grammatical structure your audience is familiar with. This heightens the ease of communication and removes unnecessary ambiguity. The rules allow you to write what you mean and mean what you write; if you do a good job your reader will know exactly what you're trying to say. Prose is a representation of your conscious thoughts, altered to a form other people can more easily understand. I like prose; I use prose, I think everyone should use prose if at all possible. I recognize, however, that some things cannot.

In poetry, the structure has some purpose other then to clarify the content. At the very least poems use structure to make the content more appealing or attractive, but this only touches upon the true potential of poetry.

Prose is great, it allows you to put your thoughts in nice little boxes for easy transport. Unfortunately all thoughts do not fit in nice little boxes; language is ofttimes a poor tool at best to express the whole of human experience. The structure which prose follows is designed for clarity, not depth or breadth. By playing around with the rules of language one can enhance the scope of communication, though at the likely sacrifice of ease of understanding.

Some poetry is more structured then prose. This additional structure forces the author to be more creative; to find ways of saying things which do not disrupt the flow. Further, the structure provides a path for the reader to follow outside the flow of the story; a good poet can achieve interesting things by playing the flow of the content off the flow of the structure. Other poetry has less structure then prose. Without the clues which grammar usually provides, a poem becomes a much more ambiguous thing. A good poem is really many poems, depending on how it's read.

Most poems, however, use a different structure then prose which has more form in some ways, less form in others. This allows the structure itself to be a means of communication as well as the content. Phrases can play off each other in ways they cannot in prose. Elements of a sentence can break out of the classic subject/predicate dichotomy. Rogue line breaks and punctuation can disrupt the flow of the reader's thoughts and force them to look at the things in a new light. Words can be distanced from their traditional meaning, allowing both writer and reader to bring in new meanings.

Prose is usually best for communication from one conscious mind to another. Poetry, on the other hand, allows for deeper communication (from one soul to soul... or perhaps just deep structure to deep structure), perhaps). Thoughts, emotions, and feelings can all be transmitted through both prose and poetry, but prose depends solely on the standard meanings of words to do so. This is fine, as long as ones thoughts, feelings, and emotions are covered by the standard meaning of words. If not, you'll have to resort to poetry to communicate. Through the combination of words and structure you can perhaps convey what you want to others, though your chances of being misunderstood have increased.

Really, though, this is not such a bad thing. Being misunderstood can even be a good thing. Most prose has only one (or at most two or three) meanings. Writing a piece of prose is certainly a creative effort, but reading one is tends to be only a passive (if hopefully entertaining or informative) one. It should inspire thought, but more often only the thoughts the writer intended. Reading a piece of poetry, on the other hand, requires a lot creative effort. One must interpret the artist's words though ones own thoughts and experiences, which often generates new ideas that the author never intended. Hence it is a doubly creative process.

To continue- According to the likes of Robert Frost, Pablo Neruda, and William Shakespeare, the basis of a poem is a metaphor. A metaphor is a delicious way of saying one thing and meaning a completly different thing. It allows us to be more vague. This gives many people trouble, because as humans we strive for certainty and clarity of understanding, ie: truth, in everything. Poems clash directly with logic. Most metaphors, logically, do not make sense. They are not true, in the literal sense of the word. They appeal to our abstract side. There is a good deal of debate floating about (Carl Sagan and Jacob Brownkowski epitimize the opposing viewpoints) as to what makes us human; what seperates man from beast. Are humans the only beings capable of abstract thought? What is abstract thought? At any rate, the beauty of poetry, and the gift which at the very least we humans posses in understanding it, is found in all the options presented by poetry and specifically the metaphor.

So often we feel things, or even understand things, that do not fit well into prose. There are not enough specific words to perfectly express what is inside ourselves. Plus, words are not as concrete things as we give them credit for. Such things as connotation, context, tone, syntax, and even definitions which shift over time must be taken into account.

Therein lies the rub. Or the solution. The way you like to interact with your world, will determine the way you can interact with poetry. But humankind in and of itself is lucky enough to have the choice to be vague, or not. Poetry is as personal as it is broad. Perception is a key aspect. Each of us are different, obviously. A poem can have a very wide appeal because it can make many people feel many different things. The more interpertations something has, the more ways there are to relate to it. And the poet never has to tell us what they meant in the first place. That is the essence of poetry.

I apologise for the less than factual nature of this writeup, but the previous writeups in this node have, I'm sure, adequately explored that aspect of the difference between poetry and prose.

For me, the difference between poetry and prose is one, essentially, of movement. When I write a poem, a good poem, a piece that I can be proud of, it gives me much the same sensation I get when I am dancing. I suspect this has a lot to do with how I write poetry: I focus on the metaphor or metaphors at the heart of the piece. Metaphors are how I interact with, view and explain the world around me. After exploring a particularly vibrant metaphor- such as in a poem- I sit back and feel something akin to euphoria. Prose, on the other hand, is reminiscent of walking. It can be just as pleasurable as poetry, there's no doubt about that. Sometimes I'd rather take a long, languid walk along a mountain path than dance frenziedly in a nightclub. I also incorporate many aspects of my poetry into my prose- to expand upon the metaphor, sometimes when I'm walking I break out into dance, take a few samba steps along the road (and, yes, that's something I've been known to do, particularly in recent months). But it's still walking, and thousands of others are walking alongside me.

When I dance, I dance for myself and myself alone. When I walk, I am always conscious of others around me doing the exact same thing. When I write in prose, I am constantly aware of my eventual audience, and this effects how I write. In prose, I am often stilted and wary. When I write poetry, I write it for myself above all others. It flows more easily. I've never tripped and fallen while dancing, only while walking. I like to walk. I love to dance. If I could, I would dance all the time. If I could, I would express every thought in poetry rather than just thinking in poetry.

I suppose this sounds pretentious, or at the very least, fanciful. But this, for me, is the difference between poetry and prose, especially as a largely self-taught free verse poet.

On a less personal note, poetry and prose often seem to me to have very different aims. Prose offers an explanation; poetry, a sensation or emotion. When language fails us, when there are gaps in what we can express in prose, poetry floods in.

Or maybe I'm just lazy.

Log in or register to write something here or to contact authors.