(this may be nothing more than an urban legend, but it is very much still worth noting):

Many people were angered by this song, as stated briefly above. Among them was a police chief's daughter, who happened to be named Jenny. The exchange 867 does exist here in the greater Seattle area. Numbers with 5309 as the last four digits of that exchange are now blocked, supposedly.

I heard that this song created such an outrage, that tons of people complained to the band to issue some sort of message with their song. The band, high on the success of the song, refused. As a sort of justice, a well read music magazine (the specifics as to which I am not sure of) posted all the personal and work phone numbers of the band members for people to call and harass. Today, such an outcry would not go unheard, in the light of our lawyer moderated culture. But, there seems that justice has been heard: Tommy Tutone, was definately a one-trick pony.