This document is not current, and is kept only for archival purposes. Please refer to Everything2 Help for all up-do-date help documents.
Q: Why can editors delete something I wrote on E2?
A: E2 is fundamentally a database publishing house. Look at it this way: When you click "submit" that is exactly what you are doing. You are submitting your text to the voting discretion of thousands of people and to the editorial discretion of a few dozen. Some work is not deemed acceptable to publish and E2 simply chooses not to publish it. It is not meant as a personal insult to you nor should it concern you greatly - your text is recoverable via Node Heaven. Anytime a writeup is deleted the author will get a message from Klaproth explaining why and possibly suggesting improvements for a reposting. If you did not get this msg please contact any editor and have them look into it. If you didn't understand the msg please ask an editor to explain.
The editorial staff was put together and is administrated by dem bones. You can see E2 FAQ: Klaproth for the details of deletions and feel free to message bones or any editor with questions about deletions or anything else.
Q: How am I supposed to know what's 'acceptable' and what isn't?
A: There is no way to draw a line in the sand and say "this is okay, this is not". The sand gets blown around, the tide shifts. There is no way to give an objective answer to so subjective an issue. Basic guidelines are sketched out in Everything University and the E2 FAQ: What not to do. After carefully reading these texts and taking a few hours to just look around the site you should have a pretty good idea of what stays and what goes.
Q: Should I re-submit a writeup that got deleted?
A: If one of your writeps is removed from the database it was likely intentional, but mistakes do occur. Please don't resubmit your writeup without first discussing it with a member of the editorial staff. Doing so will usually result in the writeup getting deleted again if there is no communication. Most of the userbase respects the editorial decisions made here and editors are often happy to help you re-work your writeup if it has merit.
As with most things, if you respect us we will have respect for you. If you are honestly trying to add to the overall quality and creativity of the database we will help you if you need it ... this is the first priority of the editorial staff. Please keep in mind they are all volunteers, even the owners of the website receive no money and in fact spend a great deal to keep this site open. They work here on their free time.
Q: Why don't people want to hear about my neat-o new idea for how E2 works/should work?
A: That's a good question.
I'm glad you asked that.
E2 is an ever-evolving community. Over the years we've had tens of thousands of users. I'd wager at least half of these people added their two cents on how E2 should function, what is cool about it and what isn't cool about it. Several hundred of these users have come and not left...they are here daily and have watched the whole story of E2 from the beginning. Several of these several hundred are some of the most intelligent people you will ever meet. I will give you hundred to one odds that we've considered your idea already.
I know that sounds slighting, I know it sounds pretentious and condescending but what can I tell you? The numbers are with me here. That's not to say your idea is stupid, it's quite probably not, it's just to say we've already considered the suggestion and haven't implemented it for one of a number of reasons, none of which we wish to discuss again. It's the same old problem: new user, same idea = a discussion that few want to take part in, again. Please don't take this personally, picture yourself walking into a room full of people that have been conversing constantly for three years...and you bring up something that's been talked to death, talked in circles and talked about some more. It's not your fault, but it's not the audience's fault either.
The ideal thing for anybody with an idea to do is to check out Suggestions for E2 or mention it, via private msg, to dem bones. If you don't get a quick reply from dem bones it probably means he's heard that one before and we're either working on it or it just isn't going to happen.
Q: Why isn't Everything way, way cooler than it is now??!
A: The primary reasons that any given "good idea" hasn't yet been implemented for Everything 2 are:
- Our Focus. Everything 2 is not the only project the Everything Development Company
is working on. Many ideas seem like good ones for
Everything 2 but you must understand that we're mainly
concentrating on core code for an
"Everything Engine"--a downloadable code that would allow
any website to be converted to and driven by E2's code.
You can see why many suggestions and ideas would apply
only to E2 and not be in the best interest
of a general code for an E2-run website such as Perl-Monks
- General coding feasibility--many ideas seem
simple in nature but quickly get quite complex and
time-consuming on the practical coding side.
- Manpower. Quite frankly, it's easy to come up with ideas, but takes much more effort to translate that idea into actual perl. If you'd like to help out by coding your idea your are welcome and thanked in advance! Several users have contributed to the E2 code so far and have been a great help to the site in general. Msg nate if you've got some ideas. If you'd prefer e-mail just send it to firstname.lastname@example.org
We've come a long way, baby ...and we're still moving, still evolving, slow and steady.
- That really is great.