And the nominees are:
- Alligator Man
- Gigantic Woman
- Killer Carpet
- Played By: n/a - it's a carpet
- Movie: The Creeping Terror
- Year: 1964
- Walking Tree
- Played By: unknown
- Movie: From Hell It Came
- Year: 1959
- Giant Turtle
- Played By: unknown
- Movie: Gamera, The Invincible
- Year: 1962
- Robot Space Gorilla
- Played By: John Brown
- Movie: Robot Monster
- Year: 1953
- Giant Lobster Shadow
And the winner is...the Robot Space Gorilla, from Robot Monster.