Published:


1893, also appears in 'The Memoirs of Sherlock Holmes'

Story code:
GLOR

Summary:

According to Sherlock Holmes himself, this was the first case of his
career and takes place at the estate of a friend from the
university. A man named Hudson, who obviously has had some previous
dealings with the friend's father, appears and begins to boss the
father around. Although no one seems to stand him, the father makes
him the butler of the household and he soon assumes the role of
Master of the House. Eventually Holmes' friend tires of him and sends
him away, but a few weeks later a mysterious letter arrives and upon
reading it the father dies of a stroke. It is later
discovered that the father was once involved in a prison
break and mutiny on the ship 'Gloria Scott', and that Hudson knew
his secret and threatened to expose him. Hudson disappears
without a trace, though and Holmes speulates that he has been murdered
by another of the men from the ship.

Review:

Holmes does not play a major role in this story, in fact he doesn't
do anything to alter the flow of events. The criminal (if indeed he
can be considered a criminal) is never caught, and we don't know
if he really gets killed or what happens to his killer. There are a
few interesting things though. Firstly, we get a rare peek into
Holmes' life prior to meeting Watson, and he gladly
admits that he has no real friends (except Watson, of
course). Secondly, there are some subtle details in the description
of the father in the story; he serves as a judge, but is renowned for
his mildness and compassion. Could this be because he was once
himself sentenced to deportation for the minor crime of
embezzlement?