This book was required reading for my English 110 class in the spring of 2003, and it remains on my bookshelf to this day. Krakauer's presentation of the story of Christopher McCandless is in no way unbiased or objective -- but Krakauer never claims it as either, and in many ways that makes all the difference.
Introducing McCandless in a way that shows him as a regular person -- a neighbor, your brother, or even yourself -- could not have been the easiest way for Krakauer to write this book, but it was the only responsible way to write it, and it is performed beautifully. McCandless's larger-than-life story suddenly becomes manageable, and Chris is someone you can empathize with, if not exactly feel sympathy for, which is really just as well; if one thing is clear, it is that McCandless was not the sort of person who would respond to or respect sympathy.
Krakauer relates to McCandless on a certain deep, viseral level; at times this allows him to provide valuable insight into McCandless's motivations, it can also act like a pair of blinders. Krakauer never acknowledges the sheer irresponsibility some of McCandless's actions -- not the least of which include venturing into the Alaskan backcountry without a map, proper clothing, and neither enough food or the knowledge to properly glean some from the environment in the (some would say inevitable) event of an emergency.
The book is an attempt to determine whether Chris McCandless was "a courageous idealist, or a reckless idiot." Although it is clear that he has already made up his own mind, Krakauer doesn't force the issue, and leaves the reader to draw their own conclusion. McCandless certainly had the courage of his convictions -- as much cannot be said about many idealists, reckless or no. Not to take anything away from Walden, but Thoreau was not much more than an afternoon's walk outside of Concord. One can admire his conviction and question his hubris -- and there is enough of both to go around -- but McCandless remains tantalizingly difficult to define. Krakauer comes close without turning the book into a lecture on the vitues of the buddy system -- which, in the hands of a less talented author, it might easily have become.
ISBN: 0385486804