display | more...

I thought things like this only happened in America. Several Australian Christian primary schools have banned Harry Potter, for allegedly promoting witchcraft and devil worship. The head of Australian Christian Schools Ltd., Rev. Robert Frisken, was quoted as stating that the books "invert morality". The Sydney Morning Herald reports "Reverend Frisken suggested that the books, which concentrate on magic, carry warning stickers before they are placed in school libraries."

This has led to an onslaught from defenders of the books, the best of which hails from the letters page of the MX, a trashy free tabloid. One woman referred to the Harry Potter books as "great literature". Wait a minute. Let's not go overboard here. Now, don't get me wrong, I read the first book, I like it, it's fun to read. It's well written, it has an interesting story and well-fleshed out characters. I plan on reading the others. I like this book. But "great literature"? Goodbye Shakespeare, you are needed no longer. Sod off Voltaire, you're old hat. We have J.K. Rowling.

It's very amusing to see so much fuss over such a non-issue. Banning the books is a laughably fascist practice, but on the other hand I can think of lots of things far more important than this that could do with some concentration.

I read all four Harry Potter books shortly after the fourth one was released. I, being admittedly something of a cultural elitest, had avoided them on the grounds that they were popular, and therefore couldn't be any good. But then a couple of friends reccomended them very highly, and I thought I'd give it a try. I love them. I think they're wonderful, but that's really not the point.

I remember reading an article in the newspaper, talking about the public reaction to the release of Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. Kids were lining up for several hours to buy it the day it came out.

I have been a staunch defender of them ever since.

Think about it. Young kids, say, ten or eleven years old, or even younger, are standing in line for over an hour to spend twenty dollars on an eight hundred page book.

I would hardly call this a non-issue. Whatever its faults, whatever various religious groups may say about the morality, these books have kids reading. And loving every minute of it.

And yes, there is good characterization, interesting plots, clever ideas. J.K. Rowling is a superb storyteller. I can't remember the last time I picked up a book that drew me in and kept me interested from page one as effectively as all four Harry Potter books. While no, I would not suggest that Rowling has supplanted Shakespeare as the greatest English writer, I would not hesitate to dub Harry Potter "great literature." And what's more, I think these books have done more to stimulate thinking in young children, to enhance literacy, and to develop a love of reading in young children than anything else in the past fifty years. That's a pretty big accomplishment.

Log in or register to write something here or to contact authors.