Findings:

Here's the stuff we found when you searched for "She Was Probably a Guy"

She probably thought your first language was English; your real first language was Joyce
She was so tall, and I was so in love
The flowers smiled, but she was gone
piano outside in the snow. and she was spinning
To a girl who thought she was moving away
someday, when she will think back upon the time when she was as yet undishonored
The House on the Island Where She Was Born
She moved so easily all I could think of was sunlight
Her innocence fell. She kicked at it some, frowned, and left it there because it was beautiful.
Jessica, too tall but still lovely, was not sure she would or should drop the whale
When that cow would walk it was like she was dancing
She was cilantro, jalapeño, habanero. She was the hot plate you must not touch.
she was just the dry smell of gasoline
A dose of mystery slipped into her cocktail while she was in the ladies' room
She was a Surrealist Woman, She was like a Figure in a Dream
She dreamt she was a bulldozer, she dreamt she was alone in an empty field
she was once a stealthy ghostship in the fog, now she shines wherever she walks
She didn't write like Emily Dickinson, but she did live in a house overlooking a cemetery, and I guess he thought that was important.
She was too beautiful to be human
she was waylaid by an octopus
She was very beautiful. Y'know?
Fast-talking career gal who thought she was one of the boys
When she was new, she rolled around the sky like a black umbrella blown by the wind
When she was bad
She grew a little older, while he was telling her
She was buttery. She was asking for it. She was delicious. Let's all give in.
She was locked in time
I was tired. It was late. She was Russian.
it was just as if she held her breath for 82 years
She was an intellectual prostitute, seducing me with profound truisms
She was the prettiest, loveliest cat at the ball and she had upon her fine gilded whiskers.
And when she came back she was nobody's wife
Outside the train station she was the only person wearing an Orange raincoat and a look of surprise
She was pain and pleasure all at once, wrapped up in needles and Ramones T-shirts
She always was devious in her beauty
"He was a terrible man," she sobbed, between bites of alimony
She was coming out as he was going in.
He was an ant on an ill-defined mission. She was the trapdoor spider of love.
you never once told her how beautiful she was nor how much you truly loved her
She was free
I'll tell you what kind of guy I was
She was the cutest necromancer I ever did see
that pain was something I needed, and probably did to myself
The highlight of my night was two guys kissing
For a lawyer she was surprisingly like a child. Sometimes.
She was a committed romantic and an anarcha-feminist. This was hard for her because it meant she couldn't blow up beautiful buildings.
What the hell was she thinking?
She was steady
If a woman lactates honey, she probably has cooter bees
He stretched out his arms but she was not there
All the while he was talking she was thinking what his whiskers would feel like on the back of her neck
In a quiet grove of pines under a frosty sky, he helped her out of the sack. She wore severe white hospital pajamas and was beautiful.
He dreamt he was a bulldozer, she dreamt she was alone in an empty bed
I'm sorry I was speeding, officer, but I really have to get to the hospital
She was never mine. I always shared her.
She was so pleased to learn that she was right
She was thinking of a boy in California who had a couch and a job
She was the seed of a strange tomorrow
The Abridged Edition: She was to one side, he was to the other, an untested bridge between them
The emotion on her face was always the one that she was feeling in her heart
I said I was sorry. Then she looked at me.
Existentialism is that girlfriend who cheated on you. Postmodernism is who she was with.
I was throwing around useless proverbs when all she needed was to be held and told that she was beautiful
She was inside the music, with her eyes closed
She had become a mutton for punishment and he was a wolf
Her self image was not the force field she imagined it to be
She was so quiet that nobody heard her
She was like a candle in the wind: unreliable
She is and was
She was most amazed by the obvious, like January and the fact that I could not possibly keep her.
She was watching me and I didn’t know it.
So I was balls deep in the guy's ass that night when he turns to me and asks for a kiss. Damn. What a fag.
She always was all tea and oranges that came all the way from China
When the best rapper was white, the best golfer was black, and the tallest guy in the NBA was Chinese
She knew what she was doing
She was feminine in the most displaced sense I had ever seen, a known quality refracted through stained glass windows.
Because, perhaps she was cold
The day I found out I was a guy
She Was 18, It Was Summer
She didn't know what outside was anymore.
She was cilantro, jalepeno, habanero. She was the hot plate you must not touch.
Besides the part where she was the only one
The girl didn't know if she was loved until he said yes.
I was a nice guy once
little pieces of her tragically poetic attempts at being loved that she was startlingly aware of, today
She doesn't really want a nice guy
The Girl Was a Guy
Some guy named Chris (user)
Guy Gavriel Kay
The Tall Guy
Comic Book Guy
Guy Kawasaki
Bill Nye the Science Guy
The Humble Guys
Family Guy
Nik and the Nice Guys
right guy
tough guy
The Cable Guy
Guy Fawkes
Guy Debord
Nice guys finish last
Exquisite Dead Guy
Arcata Guy (user)
You just cut that guy off
Fall guy
just a guy (user)
Good? Bad? I'm the guy with the gun.
Desperate guys who 'talk' me for no apparent reason
guy bob receptacles (user)
sane guy (user)
So, who is this Webster 1913 guy, anyway?
Dead Guy Ale
What Italian guys are really talking about when they say "Ey Oh"
Can I nominate this guy for sainthood?
Two Guys from Andromeda
guys in Speedos
Heavy Weapons Guy
Two Guys, a Girl & a Pizza Place
The Guy Nod
How to tell when a guy just wants to be friends
Menards guy
How to piss off the guys in the fire truck
Why guys care if their partner spits or swallows
Why some guys don't pick up on hints from women
Small-framed Guy
Inflatable Big Black Guy
The guy who may as well already be dead and therefore doesn't care about the consequences of his actions and is able to move with perfect freedom for the remainder of what will likely be a tragically short life
Before we dump the bodies, you guys wanna go to Hooters?
The kinda guy whose SO wants to install a video camera in his head
Wild and Crazy Guy
Guy Daikouji
Guy Clark
West Country Guy (user)
He's a good guy friend
The three kinds of nice guys
I'm a decent guy's worst nightmare
Why I like this Joseph Lieberman guy
date movies for guys
Are J.D. Salinger and Thomas Pynchon the same guy?
Anecdote involving a toilet and a drunk guy
Three guys whose voices are like clear glass
How to tell if a guy is circumcised from across the bar
getting hit by a guy
Strong Guy
Guy Ritchie
That guy issue
The little guy
Operation Good Guys
Good-looking guy game
Teeny Little Super Guy
Crazy People Always Think I'm the Sweetest Guy
Guy Incognito (user)
Guy Williams
The guy who talks to you while you're taking a piss
funny fat guy who dies
good guy mob
I Kissed "Weird Al" Yankovic and All I Got Was This Lousy T-shirt
fat guys
Ugly Naked Guy
Guy Pearce
Never kick a guy in the crotch!
Fry Guys
Underwater Guy
Great tricks to play on the new kid on the job
A Fantastic story from an old guy
Guy Fawkes Day
Fry Guy
justa guy (user)
The Happy Guy
Guy Verhofstadt
Quake Guy
Five Guys Named Moe
Buddy Guy
Buddy Guy's Legends
We Are All in the Dumps With Jack and Guy
cool guy (user)
Bad Guy (user)
It takes two guys to do half a woman's job
The Red Guy
What guys do with their penis
Guy Gardner

If you Log in you could create a "She Was Probably a Guy" node. If you don't already have an account, you can register here.